Transportation Problem Solver (VAM + MODI)
Transportation Problem Calculator with Steps (up to 21Γ21)
Transportation Problem Calculator
Solve with NW corner, least cost, row/column minima, VAM, Russell, and optional optimization (MODI or Stepping Stone). For large matrices, Results and Step tables are rendered only when you expand/click.
Inputs
Beginner mode adds formulas, VAM penalty tables, MODI/Stepping Stone loop breakdown, and final verification checks.
Bulk paste / import (recommended for large matrices)
Costs: rows separated by new lines; values separated by commas/spaces/tabs. Supply and demand: comma/space separated.
Results
Enter your costs + supply + demand, then click Solve. (Or click Load example.)
Export full report
Export a complete worked solution (copy/paste friendly).
Choose Word-friendly text to paste into Word (no technical skills required). Use HTML for rich formatting.
Embed this calculator
Add this free standards-based calculator to your site β no signup required.
Clicking the button copies an iframe + attribution link (required).
Calculation steps (detailed; tables lazy-load for large matrices)
Steps will appear after you solve. For large matrices, tables are generated only when expanded/clicked.
Understanding the results
How to Read the Solution (Allocation Table)
Understanding the Transportation Matrix
- Allocation matrix shows how much to ship from each source to each destination (β means 0 shipment).
- Minimum total cost is computed as ΣΣ(cᡒⱼ à xᡒⱼ) using the balanced matrix used by the solver.
- If the problem is unbalanced, a dummy source/destination is added to balance totals. Dummy shipments are a modeling device and may not represent real routes.
Common mistakes
- Mixing cost units (per-mile vs per-trip vs per-unit) inside the same matrix.
- Treating dummy allocations as real shipments rather than a balancing artifact.
- Turning off optimization and assuming the initial method is always optimal.
Limitations
This solver addresses the classic transportation model. It does not include route capacity constraints, fixed costs, time windows, integer/lot-size restrictions, multi-commodity constraints, or real-world feasibility checks beyond supply/demand balancing. Always validate against your actual constraints.
Questions People Ask
Balanced vs unbalanced, initial methods, MODI vs Stepping Stone, degeneracy, and interpreting results.
What does this Transportation Problem Solver calculate?
It finds a feasible shipping plan and its minimum total cost, starting with VAM, Northwest Corner or Least Cost and then optimising with MODI or Stepping Stone.
What is the difference between a balanced and unbalanced transportation problem?
It is balanced when total supply equals total demand. If they differ, a dummy source or destination with zero cost is added to balance it.
What is Vogelβs Approximation Method (VAM) and why is it recommended?
VAM builds a starting plan by allocating first where the penalty (the gap between the two cheapest costs) is largest, which usually gives a near-optimal start.
What is the MODI method in the transportation problem?
MODI (the uβv method) tests whether a plan is optimal by calculating potentials for rows and columns and a reduced cost for every unused route.
What is the Stepping Stone method and how is it different from MODI?
Stepping Stone tests each unused route with a closed loop, while MODI gets the same reduced costs faster by using uβv potentials.
How do I know if my transportation solution is optimal?
It is optimal when no unused route has a negative reduced cost (all dα΅’β±Ό β₯ 0 in MODI), so no move can lower the total cost.
What is degeneracy in transportation problems (and what is epsilon Ξ΅)?
Degeneracy is when a plan has fewer than m + n β 1 allocations. A tiny amount Ξ΅ is placed in an empty cell so the optimality test can run.
How is total transportation cost calculated?
Multiply each shipped quantity by its route cost and add them up: total cost = Ξ£ cα΅’β±Ό Γ xα΅’β±Ό.
How do I paste a large cost matrix from Excel or Google Sheets?
Copy the cells from Excel or Google Sheets and paste them into the bulk import box, one row per line, with values separated by tabs, spaces or commas.
Sources
- Hamdy A. Taha, Operations Research: An Introduction (Pearson). PDF
- Hillier & Lieberman, Introduction to Operations Research (McGraw-Hill). PDF
- Firas Hamid Thanoon, Proposed Method for Solving Transportation Problems. ResearchGate
- Peter MalackΓ½ & Radovan MadleΕΓ‘k, Transportation problems and their solutions: literature review. ScienceDirect
- GeeksforGeeks overview (educational). Transportation problem intro
How this calculator works (methodology)
Vogelβs Approximation Method (VAM)
VAM computes penalties (difference between the two smallest costs) for each row and column, then allocates where the penalty is largest.
Method summary
The solver can generate an initial feasible shipping plan using several classic methods (NW corner, least cost, row/column minima, VAM, Russell), and then (optionally) improve/prove optimality using MODI (uβv) or the Stepping Stone method.
Minimize: Z = ΣΣ (c_ij * x_ij) Subject to: For each source i: Ξ£ x_ij = s_i For each destination j: Ξ£ x_ij = d_j x_ij β₯ 0 MODI reduced cost: d_ij = c_ij β (u_i + v_j) Stepping Stone opportunity cost: Ξ_ij = sum(+c) β sum(βc) along the closed loop through cell (i,j)
Note: In practice, MODI and Stepping Stone identify the same improving moves; theyβre two standard ways to test/improve optimality.
Assumptions
- Shipping cost per unit is constant on each route, so total cost is linear in the amount shipped.
- Supplies and demands are known; a dummy source or destination balances them if totals differ.
- Any amount can be shipped on any route unless you block it.
Related and other calculators
Other tools that pair well with the transportation problem.
Disclaimer
Please read before relying on this page. The Transportation Problem Solver optimises the costs, supplies and demands you enter. Real logistics involve capacity, timing and contract rules that a basic model does not include. Use it for study and planning, and check the model before acting on it.
Your responsibility. Results are estimates for general information and education only, and nothing here is professional advice. You use this page at your own risk; to the fullest extent permitted by law, CalcTypes, its authors and reviewers accept no liability for loss, injury or damage arising from reliance on it. Spotted an error? Use βReport an issueβ or our contact page. Full terms: Disclaimer Β· Terms of use.